Karni Eldad

Karni Eldad is a journalist, columnist, and editor.

The absurdity of sanctions against Israel

Australia has joined Britain in imposing sanctions on Israeli individuals and organizations over their activities in Judea and Samaria. But according to Karni Eldad, the Palestinian workers who depend on the settlements for their livelihoods could end up paying the price. In the name of fighting the occupation, the consequences for the very people these measures are supposed to protect are being ignored. 

"Following Britain's lead, Australia has announced sanctions against three Israelis and four Israeli organizations over settlement construction. Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong announced sanctions against Daniella Weiss, Eliav Libi, Itamar Yehuda Levi, the Nachala movement, the Amana organization, Hashomer Yosh and Levi's construction company, Eyal Harei Yerushalayim Ltd."

Well done, Australia! You've proven that you're on the side of the good guys, those who oppose the occupation. And not just oppose it, but actually do something about it. I imagine Penny Wong went to bed that night with the satisfied smile of someone who had done a good deed. Perhaps she even got a gold star sticker and proudly placed it on the chart on her refrigerator.

The people who were smiling a little less that night were the hundreds of Palestinians employed by Amana. They feared that if the sanctions continued or intensified, they might lose their jobs, and with them their livelihoods and their ability to feed their children. They probably figured Penny Wong wouldn't be much help on that front. Sanctions are more her specialty. Because for Wong, putting food on the tables of these workers' families is hardly a top priority. She would rather impose populist sanctions without considering their consequences.

In the interest of full disclosure, what Palestinian families have for dinner isn't particularly high on my list of concerns either. I favor minimizing friction with the enemy population. What bothers me here is the double standard. Does Wong really believe her sanctions will persuade Daniella Weiss to abandon her activities because she can no longer surf at Bondi Beach? Or that Eliav Libi will dismantle his company because he'd rather spend an evening at the Sydney Opera House?

Everyone knows that both the British and Australian sanctions amount, at most, to a minor inconvenience. In this week's Torah portion, our forefather Jacob has his extraordinary dream. Against the backdrop of God's angels ascending and descending a ladder, God blesses him: "And in thee and in thy seed shall all the families of the earth be blessed" (Genesis 28:14). That blessing is being fulfilled.

Since the modern Jewish return to Zion, the families of the earth have also enjoyed its blessings. We returned to the land promised to our forefathers and brought prosperity and abundance with us. As a result, other peoples, Arabs and other minorities, were drawn to a place where earning a living was easier. That is simply the way of the world.

We don't need to go back to the beginning of the last century to see how we bring blessings to the families of the earth. Just compare the economic conditions of people living in Judea and Samaria, where we live, with those of Gaza, from which we were expelled 21 years ago.

The people of Gaza still depend on humanitarian aid. That isn't a blessing, It's dependency. It isn't growth, It's stagnation. When we were there, the land flourished. It produced extraordinary agricultural abundance, some of which was exported abroad. We developed new farming methods and crop varieties that benefited us, the world and, yes, the Palestinian laborers employed by the residents.

What stopped them from continuing to prosper? Strangling Israeli companies that build in Judea and Samaria also harms the Palestinian population.

Those planning to impose sanctions on these companies should take that into account and say it plainly: I want Palestinians to suffer. That's a price I'm willing to pay.

Related Posts