Sunday Jul 20, 2025
NEWSLETTER
www.israelhayom.com
  • Home
  • News
    • Israel
    • Israel at War
    • Middle East
    • United States
  • Opinions
  • Jewish World
    • Archaeology
    • Antisemitism
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Fashion
    • Culture
  • Magazine
    • Feature
    • Analysis
    • Explainer
  • In Memoriam
www.israelhayom.com
  • Home
  • News
    • Israel
    • Israel at War
    • Middle East
    • United States
  • Opinions
  • Jewish World
    • Archaeology
    • Antisemitism
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Fashion
    • Culture
  • Magazine
    • Feature
    • Analysis
    • Explainer
  • In Memoriam
www.israelhayom.com
Home News

Appeals court upholds constitutionality of terror watchlist

"This is no program of marginal consequence," writes Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson. "It lies at the very heart of our country's effort to identify those who would inflict upon the public irretrievable loss."

by  AP and ILH Staff
Published on  03-31-2021 16:19
Last modified: 03-31-2021 15:29
Appeals court upholds constitutionality of terror watchlistReuters / Adrees Latif
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A federal appeals court on Tuesday overturned a challenge to the constitutionality of the government's terrorist watchlist, ruling that the government deserves wide latitude in establishing programs designed to protect national security.

Follow Israel Hayom on Facebook and Twitter

A group of two dozen Muslim plaintiffs sued in 2016, saying their placement on the list had caused all kinds of difficulties in traveling and in other aspects of life. And they said the government's administration of the list gave them no meaningful way to clear their name when they were wrongly placed on the list.

A federal judge in Alexandria, Virginia, ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in 2019, but the government appealed.

On Tuesday a three-judge panel of the 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond ruled unanimously in favor of the government. The panel reversed the district court's decision, sent the case back to the judge and ordered him to rule in favor of the government.

"(T)his is no program of marginal consequence," wrote Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson. "It lies at the very heart of our country's effort to identify those who would inflict upon the public irretrievable loss."

More than 1 million names are on the watchlist, also known as the Terrorist Screening Database, and are considered by the government to be "known or suspected terrorists." Of those, only a handful – about 4,600 – are US citizens.

Various government agencies use and have access to the list. The much smaller No Fly List is compiled from the watchlist. A broader subset of the watchlist, known as the Selectee List, includes people who are allowed to board flights but are subjected to additional scrutiny. Government officials said the Selectee List can be used to determine which flights will include air marshals, for example.

The plaintiffs alleged a wide variety of harms because of their apparent inclusion on the list. Some said they were subjected to humiliating questions and disparate treatment at airport security. Some allegations were more severe – one plaintiff said he was detained at a border crossing by agents with guns drawn in front of his family, then left handcuffed and freezing in a cold cell for hours until he passed out.

The plaintiffs said they were wrongly placed on the list simply because they are Muslim.

While the appeals court ruled in favor of the government, Wilkinson said the plaintiffs are not totally without recourse if their rights are violated. He said, for instance, that individuals can file lawsuits claiming they were subjected to unreasonable search and seizures under the 4th Amendment.

But he said a broad attack on the program as a whole could do more harm than good.

"Courts lack the expertise and competence to second-guess decisions made about national security needs," he wrote.

Gadeir Abbas, a lawyer with the Council on American-Islamic Relations, argued the case on behalf of the plaintiffs. He said he will ask the full 4th Circuit to review the case.

"This panel's decision ignores how the federal government's secret watchlist has terrorized the Muslim community for almost two decades," he said. "We are hopeful that the entire Fourth Circuit will review this decision."

All three judges who heard the case are GOP appointees  – Wilkinson was appointed by former President Ronald Reagan and the other two were appointed by former President Donald Trump.

 Subscribe to Israel Hayom's daily newsletter and never miss our top stories!

Related Posts

IDF probes reports of casualties at Gaza aid centers

by Lilach Shoval

The terrorist organization Hamas claimed that Gazans were killed while waiting for aid distribution. A preliminary investigation by the IDF...

Former hostage reveals horrific torture witnessed in Gaza captivityEPA/MOHAMMED SABER

Former hostage reveals horrific torture witnessed in Gaza captivity

by ILH Staff

Keith Siegel describes seeing female captive tortured with sharp rod, calls for comprehensive deal to bring all remaining hostages home.

Israel to expel senior UN official over bias on Gaza warOCHA

Israel to expel senior UN official over bias on Gaza war

by Ariel Kahana

The decision not to renew visa of Jonathan Whittall comes after OCHA repeatedly issued distorted reports about Gaza operations, with...

Menu

Analysis 

Archaeology

Blogpost

Business & Finance

Culture

Exclusive

Explainer

Environment

 

Features

Health

In Brief

Jewish World

Judea and Samaria

Lifestyle

Cyber & Internet

Sports

 

Diplomacy 

Iran & The Gulf

Gaza Strip

Politics

Shopping

Terms of use

Privacy Policy

Submissions

Contact Us

About Us

The first issue of Israel Hayom appeared on July 30, 2007. Israel Hayom was founded on the belief that the Israeli public deserves better, more balanced and more accurate journalism. Journalism that speaks, not shouts. Journalism of a different kind. And free of charge.

All rights reserved to Israel Hayom

Hosted by sPD.co.il

  • Home
  • News
    • Israel at War
    • Israel
    • United States
    • Middle East
    • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Jewish World
    • Archaeology
    • Antisemitism
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Fashion
    • Culture
  • Magazine
    • Feature
    • Analysis
    • Explainer
    • Environment & Wildlife
    • Health & Wellness
  • In Memoriam
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Submit your opinion
  • Terms and conditions

All rights reserved to Israel Hayom

Hosted by sPD.co.il

Newsletter

[contact-form-7 id=”508379″ html_id=”isrh_form_Newsletter_en” title=”newsletter_subscribe”]

  • Home
  • News
    • Israel at War
    • Israel
    • United States
    • Middle East
    • Sports
  • Opinions
  • Jewish World
    • Archaeology
    • Antisemitism
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Fashion
    • Culture
  • Magazine
    • Feature
    • Analysis
    • Explainer
    • Environment & Wildlife
    • Health & Wellness
  • In Memoriam
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Submit your opinion
  • Terms and conditions

All rights reserved to Israel Hayom

Hosted by sPD.co.il