It's time to take the coronavirus threat seriously.
That's as true for local Jewish communities as it is for governments. But just like some of our leaders have been slow to comprehend the peril from the spread of the disease, the same is true for those in charge of schools, synagogues and communal organizations. Now that more cases are being reported, there's little doubt that canceling events and reverting to virtual services or classes where possible is rapidly becoming an imperative, and the reason for doing so is rooted in faith as much as in common sense.
Few governments seem to have been prepared for the spread of coronavirus, COVID-19, which rapidly spread across the globe in recent weeks. In many places, the impulse to downplay the risk of the contagion slowed the decision-making process to impose quarantines, travel restrictions, as well as expediting testing and other measures that can help decelerate the spread of the virus.
Follow Israel Hayom on Facebook and Twitter
Regimes such as China – which is believed to be where the coronavirus originated – and Iran restricted information for the same reason authoritarian governments always do. They feared that transparency about any public-safety threat will undermine their authority and the result was, as is always, that a bad situation was made much worse.
Yet coronavirus is as much of a challenge to democracies. Blaming leaders for failing to act quickly enough is reasonable, but politicizing public health is a topic not so easily pigeonholed in our usual compartments, where we all damn those with whom we disagree on other issues. Coronavirus isn't a hoax dreamed up by President Donald Trump's critics in order to take him down any more than it is, as one Washington Post columnist disgracefully characterized it: "Trump's Chernobyl."
The real problem is that most of us are resistant to the idea that our lives must be inconvenienced in order to reduce the risk of contagion, while at the same time we are all too ready to believe conspiracy theories, and that the very worst is possible.
Far too much of our popular culture is rooted in dystopian fantasies about zombie apocalypses, diseases that can wipe out the world and evil governments that are either facilitating these terrible things or not doing enough to stop them. That's why many of us are ready to believe such a thing can happen, while at the same time dismissing the possibility that it's happening right now.
Listen to medical experts and you will receive a sobering lecture about how easily the illness spreads, as well as the very real scenarios in which large numbers of those who are more vulnerable to the disease – a category that includes, but is not strictly limited to, the elderly and those with pre-existing health conditions. They are also saying that this is not the bubonic plague nor the 1919 Spanish.
Pop culture has conditioned us to think that, sooner or later, we'll wake up one day and learn that – as was the case in the 14th century – that a disease is killing a huge percentage of humanity. It's also true that a century ago, the flu killed millions. But coronavirus is not the Black Death. Nor is today's situation comparable to the post-World War I world in which huge populations of vulnerable civilians and soldiers were felled by the flu before the advent of antibiotics.
Just because the coronavirus isn't going to kill all of us doesn't mean that drastic measures aren't sometimes necessary. The need to avoid spreading panic with irresponsible talk about politicized conspiracy theories and dystopian fantasies is no excuse for thinking that, at least for the short term, we can keep on with business as usual.
Israel's rapid implementation of tough quarantine measures, expanded on Monday shortly before the country started celebrating Purim (anyone entering the country must self-quarantine for 14 days, including Israeli citizens), was the right way to respond to the problem. The United States has been slow to implement similar measures but ought to be moving in that direction.
In that same spirit, while the unwillingness of many community institutions to consider canceling Purim carnivals, religious services and school classes may be rooted in a sensible desire to refuse to succumb to panic, there's good reason to believe that it is necessary in areas where cases of coronavirus have been reported.
Programs involving international travel, such as the annual March of the Living program, which takes students to Poland to see the death camps of the Holocaust and then moves on to Israel, simply had to be postponed.
But the impulse to simply shut down life and commerce altogether should be resisted – not just because there is no rational reason to believe it is necessary, but also because spreading panic does genuine harm. Charting a course in which sensible precautions are employed while avoiding the spread of fear goes against every instinct that our current political and entertainment culture has fostered. Yet as the toll of coronavirus grows and the disease runs its course, it is vital for us to resist the temptation to downplay or exaggerate the threat. It's equally necessary to understand that even in a free society, citizens must sometimes sacrifice some of their freedoms for the sake of public health.
As always, it is important to look to our spiritual heritage and realize that the answer lies there. The Jewish religious principle of pikuach nefesh – the idea that the saving lives can and must mandate the overriding of almost all other rules, laws and considerations – must prevail. Neither politics nor personal convenience can be allowed to intrude on that imperative.
Reprinted with permission from JNS.org
